Blog · Selling a Home · Ask Andrew
What Is a VA Tidewater Notice, and What Can Arizona Home Sellers Do About It?
A VA Tidewater notice is an early warning from the VA appraisal process that the appraiser may have difficulty supporting the contract price, delivered before the appraisal is finalized. It opens a short window, ordinarily about two business days, to submit additional comparable-sale evidence. It is not a final value, and it is not the same as a post-appraisal Reconsideration of Value.
The short answer
A Tidewater notice is the VA appraisal process asking for more evidence before the appraisal is finalized, not a finished value and not a rejection of the price. The response window is short, usually about two business days, and a well-prepared submission can make sure the property's distinctive characteristics and the best available comparable sales are part of the record.
What a VA Tidewater notice means
When a buyer uses a VA-backed loan, the VA appraisal is ordered to make sure the property supports the loan amount. If the appraiser's initial analysis suggests the contract price may not be supported by the comparable sales available, the appraiser notifies the designated point of contact, usually the lender, through a process the VA calls Tidewater. The notice is a request for additional evidence, not a finished opinion of value: the appraisal has not been completed yet, and the appraiser is asking whether more relevant market data exists that could support the contract price.
Why an appraiser may issue one before completing the appraisal
The VA appraisal process is designed to reach a supportable value before a report is issued. When the appraiser reviews the initial comparable sales and the contract price appears higher than the evidence supports, Tidewater gives the parties a chance to respond before the appraisal is finalized. The alternative would be a completed report at a lower value, followed by a lengthier challenge after the fact. Tidewater exists so the most relevant evidence can be considered at the point where it can still inform the final value.
The two-business-day window to submit evidence
Under the VA's Tidewater process, the appraiser ordinarily allows about two business days for the response. That window is short by design: the goal is to gather additional comparable-sale evidence, not to stall the appraisal. A strong response typically includes recent sales the appraiser may not have used, with the details that make them relevant to the subject property. Acting quickly matters, because once the window closes the appraiser completes the appraisal with the evidence available.
What makes a comparable sale comparable
Comparable sales are the backbone of any appraisal, but a similar floor plan alone does not make one home equivalent to another. Appraisers weigh lot size, location, amenities, condition, and the adjustments the market supports for each difference. A home with the same floor plan on a substantially smaller lot is not automatically comparable to a home with a large corner lot, a pool, and a sports court. The question is whether the differences are supported by market evidence, and by how much.
Tidewater is not a Reconsideration of Value
A Reconsideration of Value, or ROV, is a different step: it happens after the appraisal has been completed and issued, when one side asks the appraiser to reconsider the value based on additional information. Tidewater happens before the appraisal is finalized, as part of the appraisal itself. The distinction matters because the two processes have different timing, different procedures, and different expectations about what the appraiser will consider.
The agent's role: advocate with evidence, not demands
An agent's job in a Tidewater response is to present objective, relevant evidence, not to demand a predetermined result. The appraiser is an independent professional, and no agent controls the appraised value. What a well-prepared response can do is make sure the property's distinctive characteristics and the best available comparable sales are part of the record before the value is finalized. That is what advocacy means in practice: investigating the facts, understanding the market, and making a well-supported case.
If the final appraisal comes in below the contract price
If the appraisal is completed below the contract price, buyers and sellers still have options. The buyer can ask the lender about a Reconsideration of Value with additional evidence, negotiate a different price with the seller, bring additional funds to cover part or all of the gap, or, depending on the contract, walk away under the appraisal contingency. Sellers can respond by reviewing the report and the evidence, and by considering whether the price or the terms should change. Every situation is different, and the right path depends on the contract, the financing, and the numbers.
The honest caveat
A Tidewater response does not guarantee a higher valuation or an on-time closing, and outcomes vary from transaction to transaction. The process gives the parties a chance to put the best evidence in front of the appraiser before the appraisal is finalized; it does not promise a result.
Real-world example
For a documented example of how a Tidewater response can play out, read How a VA Tidewater Response Helped Keep a $315,000 Buckeye Home Sale on Track , a December 2019 Buckeye case study in which an evidence-based response addressed a home that wasn't like the model-match homes around it.
Official VA guidance
- VA Circular 26-17-18 (PDF) · benefits.va.gov · the Tidewater process guidance
- VA home loan appraisal page · benefits.va.gov · appraisers and the appraisal process
Educational note: this article explains the VA Tidewater process in general terms, using current official VA guidance. Appraisal practices, timelines, and outcomes vary by property and transaction, and nothing here is a valuation, a loan decision, or a guarantee of any result. Confirm the details of your specific transaction with your lender, your agent, and the VA.
Next step
Got a VA appraisal question on your sale?
Walk through the Tidewater process, the evidence that matters, and your options with a local agent who will lay out the tradeoffs.
- Phone
- 623-400-5957
- hello@clearlysold.com