Success Story · Seller Advocacy · Buckeye, Arizona
How a VA Tidewater Response Helped Keep a $315,000 Buckeye Home Sale on Track
In December 2019, I represented homeowners selling a distinctive property in Buckeye, Arizona. The buyers were obtaining VA financing, and during escrow we received a Tidewater notification indicating that the appraiser had concerns about supporting the purchase price.
Rather than accept the possibility of a valuation shortfall without examining the evidence, I prepared a detailed market response demonstrating why nearby homes with similar floor plans weren't necessarily equivalent to my clients' property.
The Home That Wasn't Like the Others
The sellers' home offered 2,469 square feet of living space, four bedrooms, and three bathrooms on an approximately 14,472-square-foot interior corner lot. The backyard was the point of difference: a private swimming pool, a sports court, and substantial outdoor living space, with updated kitchen and bathrooms inside.
- 2,469 square feet Living space
- Four Bedrooms
- Three Bathrooms
- Approximately 14,472 square feet Lot
- Interior corner lot Setting
- Private pool, sports court, substantial outdoor living Backyard
- Updated kitchen and bathrooms Interior
That lot mattered to these buyers from the start. When they originally purchased the home, they specifically declined the same floor plan on smaller lots. The outdoor space was not a bonus they tolerated; it was a reason they chose this property.
A Tidewater Notification During Escrow
The buyers were financing the purchase with a VA loan, and during escrow the VA appraisal process raised a concern about supporting the contract price before the appraisal was finalized. That notification, known as a Tidewater notice, signals that the appraiser may have difficulty supporting the agreed price based on the comparable sales available at the time.
A Tidewater notice is not a finished appraisal and not a final value. It is an early, structured invitation to put additional market evidence in front of the appraiser before the report is completed. For my clients, that meant the outcome was not settled yet, and the evidence deserved a closer look.
Seeking Expertise and Building the Response
When the Tidewater notification arrived, I contacted George, a fellow Realtor, veteran, and veterans' advocate, to make sure I understood the VA appraisal process correctly and to build the strongest possible response. George provided expertise and collaboration on the applicable VA process; my role was seller representation and advocacy for my clients. George was not the listing agent, and neither of us determined the appraised value.
George recommended requesting a value of $301,000, and that was the value formally requested in the submitted Tidewater documentation. At the same time, I continued advocating for a full evaluation of the subject property's distinctive characteristics against the $315,000 contract price.
Looking Beyond the Floor Plan
The response centered on a simple observation: several nearby properties had similar floor plans but substantially smaller lots. A model-match comparison alone did not fully address the subject property's distinctive features.
The report I prepared contained comparable sales, market statistics, property-specific adjustments, supporting MLS information, and geographic comparisons. The analysis emphasized lot size, competing property characteristics, and evidence of buyer demand for larger lots.
The lot-size difference
Same floor plan, different property
2019 lot sizes from the historical market analysis.
Bar widths are proportional to lot size. Lot sizes are from the historical 2019 market analysis.
Similar floor plans alone did not make those homes equivalent. Lot size, property characteristics, and what buyers in this market were actually willing to pay for a larger lot all shaped the comparison, and the analysis put that evidence on the table.
The Outcome
The VA appraisal ultimately came in at the complete $315,000 contract price. The sellers completed the transaction without reducing the agreed purchase price because of an appraisal shortfall, and the sale closed on schedule.
$315,000
Contract Price
$315,000
Final Appraisal
Closed on Time
Sale completed on schedule
More Than an Appraisal Victory
What made this experience especially rewarding wasn't simply that the final appraisal supported our $315,000 contract price.
A VA Tidewater notification can introduce uncertainty into an already stressful transaction. My clients had plans beyond selling their house, and a valuation shortfall could have disrupted those plans.
By working collaboratively, presenting relevant market evidence, and advocating for a fuller evaluation of their property's unique characteristics, we helped keep their sale on track.
The appraisal came in at the agreed purchase price, we closed on time, and most importantly, my clients were able to move forward to the next chapter of their lives.
That's what effective real estate representation means to me. It's not just about the house or the numbers. It's about the people whose lives depend on the outcome.
What This Means for Sellers
"A strong real estate representative doesn't simply submit paperwork and hope for the best. When challenges arise, effective representation means investigating the facts, understanding the market, and making a well-supported case for the client's interests."
An appraisal concern can threaten any financed sale, and how it is handled can change the outcome. The value of experienced representation is not a promise of any particular result; it is the work of making sure the evidence is complete, the property is understood, and the client's interests are argued well. Explore the full range of seller solutions, or start with Buckeye real estate resources.
Accuracy note
- This case study describes a historical December 2019 transaction in Buckeye, Arizona.
- The Tidewater response is a historical document, not a current market analysis, and results are not typical or guaranteed.
- The response occurred before the final appraisal was completed, so no appraisal was "increased" from a prior issued value.
Educational note: this case study describes one historical transaction. Market conditions, appraisal practices, and outcomes vary by property and transaction, and nothing here is a prediction, a valuation, or a guarantee of any result.
Next step
Planning a sale in Arizona?
Appraisal concerns are one of the most common threats to a financed sale. A seller consultation covers your options, the tradeoffs, and how the evidence would be handled for your home.
- Phone
- 623-400-5957
- hello@clearlysold.com